About
a month ago when I read about Torry Hansen, the Tennessee nurse who sent her
adopted son on a plane back to Russia, what bothered me as much as how she
treated her son was what she did to the already tenuous state of Russian
international adoptions. I didn't follow it closely but I knew it was
safe to assume that Russia would put an immediate halt to in-process adoptions.
And they did.
Adoptions
disrupt. It's a sad reality but it happens and there are ways to do it
correctly. Even if Hansen was at her wit's end, it's hard for me to believe
that a woman who was still savvy enough to hire a Russian escort for her son
(once he arrived in Russia, he made the international flight alone), wasn't
capable of finding a better, kinder alternative for a son she'd previously
committed to parent. If other parents had discovered this Montana ranch,
why hadn't she? If other parents can discuss these things with their
caseworkers, take Reactive Attachment Disorder seminars, and seek support for
difficult placements why couldn't she?
In the letter Hansen sent with the boy she wrote, "I was lied to and
misled by the Russian Orphanage workers and director regarding his mental
stability and other issues..." Seriously? Yes and we were told that
Kaden had a deviated septum and all sorts of medical gobblygook that meant
nothing whatsoever. When we got him stateside we took him to the doctor and
began the very expensive process of figuring out Kaden's true medical problems
and set to work fixing them. (Haven't you heard the great adenoid surgery
debacle story of December 2005 - it's fabulous...) Did we send Russia a
bill because they'd misled us about Kaden's medical history. Uh, no, we
did not.
What we sent to Russia were our post-placement reports filled with stories of all we were doing for Kaden attached to all the required colored copies of photos of our growing boy. We did this for years not because if we didn't we could have lost our son, but because it helped ensure Russia will continue to allow foreign adoptions. Doing post placement reports helps enable more kids to get out of those orphanages. With the color copies, the apostilles, and the shipping it cost me around $30 a report, and I think I had to do them five times. Thank you, Torry Hansen, for undoing all of my efforts and all of the efforts of thousands of other families. We'll all be sending you a bill for $150.
Unless her American adoption agency blatantly lied to
her, I cannot imagine Hansen didn't have some idea that the son she was going
to adopt, a son who did not speak her language, who had been institutionalized,
whose birth mother was a known alcoholic (so who knows about her drinking
practices back during pregnancy), was going to have some bumps in his
transition process into her family. And indeed, perhaps his issues proved
too much. Maybe she got in over her head. I don't fault her for the
disruption, but the manner of the disruption was deplorable.
And that's a ridiculously long segue into some news I received from the
agency we used for Kaden's adoption. Russia has reopened adoptions.
From an email:
CWA is
delighted to once again offer the opportunity to adopt from Russia. Based
on the current process, we feel this is a good time to accept new families to
begin their adoption of a boy of any age, of a girl age 5 years and older, or
of siblings age 1-10 years old. For sibling groups families need to be open to
bringing children home up to 10 years old. The realistic youngest age at
referral for a boy is 11-12 months and up. The realistic age at referral for a
girl is 5 years and older.
You can read complete information about CWA's
Russia Adoption Program here:
http://www.cwa.org/russia-adoption.htm
Therefore,
we are once again accepting applications for Russia from families wanting a boy
of any age or a girl age 5 or older. We are also accepting applications from
families wanting to adopt siblings age 1-10 years old.
So. That’s
the current status of Russian adoptions.
And there’s my two cents on the Hansen story.
But what’s
REALLY bothered me since that whole thing is this Slate piece. The author sympathizes with Hansen and I can accept that. She works to shed light on how complicated it is to bring home a child you are supposed to love, but then reality strikes and this little person you'd fantasized snuggling over bedtime stories with and pushing on the playground swing is actually this rage-filled tyrant who doesn't want anything to do with you. I appreciate that perspective because adoptive parents-to-be need to hear it. What I can't handle is how pessimistic she remains about the whole process. She writes, "The problem is that the harm has already been done. Even the best adoption parent is just the clean-up crew."
EXCUSE ME?!
I am not JUST the clean-up crew. This line really, really, really bothers me. Like, to where I've fantasized about meeting this author, KJ Dell'Antonia, at a party and she's wearing a light color and I've got a glass of red wine and Oops! Well, oh well. I mean, you're so good at being the clean-up crew. Go to town...
But the odds of that scenario are just so minute! Instead, I internet stalked her and she has a blog and she wrote this follow-up post which has such a different tone and some lovely lines, that I've begrudgingly developed a fuller picture. See:
...because I DID read the books and I DID think about what we were doing and I DID think I was prepared-that she was really screaming about being taken away from everything she'd ever known and loved-she knows, in short, that there were moments when all she needed was comfort and I put her down and I walked away. Those were most emphatically not some loving moments.
And she knows that I don't do that anymore.
So what I think is that that's part of our story.
What Dell'Antonia is addressing here is the fact that most readers of the Slate piece were appalled to think that her daughter would someday read her words entitled, I Did Not Love My Adopted Child. I guess all those people are just nicer than me because I was just too busy being offended to worry about her daughter. The Slate piece WITH her blog serving as a companion manage to create a more satisfying bottom line - adoption can suck, but do it anyway. That, I can get behind. But if adoption can suck, and even if adoptive parents aren't JUST the clean-up crew but still are, in SOME aspects, the clean-up crew, why adopt?
Maybe before she adopted Torry Hansen was always considered to be a really nice person, but then, becoming an adoptive mother of a child she could not handle pushed her over the edge and suddenly, for about a week this past April, she was everybody's favorite person to hate. (And I do mean EVERYBODY, because this was international news.) Why would anyone risk that?!
A few weeks ago I was at lunch with a friend and she asked me if I would do anything different in terms of how we added to our family. She was mostly talking about Blue because I think this particular friend is scared of Blue's hellion antics and she marvels how I let him in my house much less read him bedtime stories and let him give me sloppy wet kisses at night. I said my only regret was that I hated being at Blue's trial at the start of my 9th month of pregnancy with Toby. I could have used a little more breathing room between all that. It was hard to go from the stress of trial to the stress of my first newborn but my 3rd kid. Crazy hard. And I just wish I could have had some more friggin' downtime!
I know my answer surprised her. She knows I bemoan how different Kaden and I are. How difficult his follower, people-pleaser personality is for me to parent. Add to that his continued language issues so I STILL feel like I don't really KNOW my son. Kaden is often hard for me to enjoy. She knows that. And Blue. Blue is Blue and he makes my scream and shout and pop blood vessels and think about kicking walls. (I've never kicked a wall.) She knows that too. And Toby. Toby is very often the best and worst part of my day. Toby's diagnosis still overwhelms me. Toby's smile and giggles are currently my favorite thing in the whole world, but he's also the reason I'm tired all the time and so dang crabby and irritable, so although I love him, 87% of the time I don't particularly like myself, and of course I'm acutely aware of how interconnected that all is, TOBY.
But at the end of the day, if Kaden struggles with language his whole life and one day I look at my 30 year-old-son and I think, I still don't know you, well, I'm still glad we got him out of that orphanage, fattened him up, got his adenoids and tonsils out, taught him about loving Jesus, the Gators, good food, and more. And I know it's a 50/50 shot Blue will either be in prison or The President but either way he's mine and I wouldn't have it any other way. Ditto for Toby no matter where his symptoms take us or science doesn't.
And I don't say that because I'm committed to being their clean-up crew. I say that because I'm committed to seeing them into the stages of their lives when they understand their first year or so and figure out how it is part of them but certainly not the sum of them.
I know I'm late to the table for this Hansen/Russian adoption discussion, but really there is no end to the fact that we all need to be discussing that adoption is hard but more of us have to do it. Kids need homes. Messy kids who require lots of clean-up need homes. But I promise, unlike the picture Dell'Antonia paints in the slate piece (but not her blog) it's not just about the clean up.
Yesterday, Blue, Toby and I were out and about at lunchtime and I did something I NEVER do. I let Blue pick our lunch stop and therefor ended up lunching at McDonald's. (Or Old McDonald's as Blue stubbornly calls it.) As we ate, I know the table next to us was delighting in the cuteness that is Toby and at down times the lady at the register maintained a conversation via hand waving with Blue. Then we played outside. I sat at the base of the plaything and Blue bolted up then yelled down, "I'm in my spaceship. It's punching you!" And sure enough the spaceship thing really did look like a boxing glove and I marveled yet again how that boy notices EVERYTHING. Meanwhile Toby was crawling over me and pulling up on other things he could reach. He'd crawl in and out of the shadows and you could SEE his thoughts, why is it so hot to touch there but not here? And in that moment (in McDonald's of all places!) I really loved my life.
And this morning I attended a kindergartner's Young Authors Party where the class read their books to an audience of their peers and a few parents. And I heard Kaden read his story, "A boy and a dog." It goes like this:
There was a boy at the park.
There was a dog there also.
They played together.
They had fun at the park.
Does it bother this MFA fiction grad that my son missed the class assigned task of adding conflict to his story? No.
My Russian born son wrote a conflict-free story that is absolutely true to the experiences of his life now. It was a joy to hear.
You have to get through the messes to get to the joys. That's parenting, regardless of the adoption aspect.